UPDATED March 8, 2009:

After a couple of days of thought about the movie Watchmen I have a couple of additions that I didn’t have when I wrote the original review. Two issues: costume /makeup and casting.
Malin Akerman: whom had the perfect look—hot! Her rendition of Silk Spectre II kicked ass, (don’t forget that!) except for a couple of scenes (which were not really in her control.) When they took her bangs away and parted her hair over her forehead—It happened only briefly, but it did interrupt the fantasy…
They used the wrong colors on her crime fighting uniform for her shoulder area or they should have given the uniform shoulder pads to build out her frame. As it was she looked small, petite, like she didn’t have a neckline—again the scenes were brief, but I’m updating my thoughts and that’s what I think.
Those were the cosmetic thoughts and now there is an issue with casting—Patrick Wilson as Nite Owl II. I really wanted to believe and like this actor in this role I immediately thought about him being in Hard Candy. Part of the reason I wanted him to well was because his performance was chilling as a predator/pedophile/killer! But I can’t get that character out of my head. So I ask why was he chosen to be a superhero? His acting skills are right on but… Maybe he looked good in the Nite Owl suit… He did have the cleft chin that looked cool with his mask.
Also, the villain Ozymandias played by Matthew Goode was just eh… Didn’t really have the look which would have been ok if he brought the attitude, but he didn’t. So, I’m not sure why he was selected… This could be because I don’t know the graphic novel version of Watchmen and it might be explained there.
Original post starts here:

Wowie Kazoo! Watchmen rocks!
I had no expectations, didn’t really know the story going in. I did know that it was based on comic books so I loosely knew it would be an action superhero type thing.
Lots of buzz on the street. I liked it! I liked it very much!
It was a long movie and I didn’t mind a bit. It wasn’t trite in the sense that it wasn’t a made for kids sensibilities—It was a comic book for adults! Ultra violence, strong language, sex—it had it all! —Including what I consider a solid plot, some really good acting especially Rorschach played by Kelly Leak from The Bad News Bears in Breaking Training days—Jackie Earle Haley, great costumes and special effects. I really liked the small details like the characters names for instance. The music also kicked a lot of ass!
I don’t know where you go from here with sequels because this was really good and my favorite character dies in the end… No spoiler because you don’t know which character was my favorite.

Billy Crudup: was solid as Dr. Manhattan. Malin Akerman: kicked ass as Silk Spectre II. Patrick Wilson as Nite Owl II did a good job making me forget his chilling character Jeff Kohlver from Hard Candy. Jeffrey Dean Morgan: as The Comedian was really a good character! Zack Snyder did and awesome job of directing—this was better that 300 !
Technorati Tags: Billy Crudup, Dr. Manhattan, Jackie Earle Haley, Jeffrey Dean Morgan, Kelly Leak, Malin Akerman, Minutemen, Nite Owl II, Patrick Wilson, Rorschach, Silk Spectre II, The Bad News Bears, The Comedian, Watchmen, Zack Snyder